OnlyBucs

Saw a you tube thing with Cutch, naming his Pirate Mount Rushmore. He only named three: Clemente, Stargell, Wagner. He said he had to think about the last guy, he'd like it to be someone who was a career Pirate. He laughed when it was suggested it be him, he said, "I'm still playing though".



So, who are your 4 guys? My ONLY stipulation is this- You can only have one guy who was never alive during your time on earth. He didn't have to still be playing. You could have been alive for one day.



Of course, Doc can pick anyone, I mean, he read Honus Wagner's birth announcement on the local papyrus and said, "Honus...that's an unusual name."



So here goes mine:

Clemente

Stargell

Parker

Cutch

You must have listened to DK's podcast. I heard the same one. It was a good discussion.



Clemente

Stargell

Parker

Wagner



Cutch isn't quite there for me, but could replace Parker. The point they made on the podcast is that Cucth is bolstered by what he means to the organization, not just in terms of numbers but in terms of helping the team end the 20 year losing streak and make the playoffs three years in a row. Parker largely built on the success of teams that had come before him.



That said, I never saw Clemente, Parker, or Stargell play.

Hard to decide after Clemente and Stargell. So I'll do a Mount Van Rushmore.



Andy Van Slyke

John Vander Wal

John Van Benschoten

John VanMeter



Honorable mention: Todd Van Poppel

Honus, Roberto, Pops, and the Cobra.

727A794E587D5A553B0 wrote: You must have listened to DK's podcast. I heard the same one. It was a good discussion.



Clemente

Stargell

Parker

Wagner



Cutch isn't quite there for me, but could replace Parker. The point they made on the podcast is that Cucth is bolstered by what he means to the organization, not just in terms of numbers but in terms of helping the team end the 20 year losing streak and make the playoffs three years in a row. Parker largely built on the success of teams that had come before him.



That said, I never saw Clemente, Parker, or Stargell play.
No, the you tube video I saw was linked from a thread on the Pirates Reddit page. I'm guessing that's possibly where someone got the idea to start the thread there.

6E434E5F58495E1E1D2C0 wrote: Hard to decide after Clemente and Stargell. So I'll do a Mount Van Rushmore. 



Andy Van Slyke

John Vander Wal

John Van Benschoten

John VanMeter



Honorable mention: Todd Van Poppel
That's awesome!

My list;



Wagner

Clemente

Stargell

Mazeroski



Tough choice with Maz over the Waners, Bonds, etc., but in the end, I went with career Pirates over guys who played elsewhere (even though Honus came from Louisville in the 1890's with Connie Mack), and Pie Traynor who I think Maz actually had better stats than.



i would never consider Ralph Kiner, but that's a personal rub and not a statistics thing.

I'd put Wagner but I want the 4 to be guys I saw play. I'd put Pie Traynor just because I loved him doing wrestling when I was a tyke.



Anywho:



#21

#8 (is that a retired #?)

#9

So many for a fourth so I'll go with a two headed monster but one body featuring Danny Murtaugh and Chuck Tanner.

Under the rules set out:



Wagner

Clemente

Stargell

Mazeroski



The all-timer and the three WS wins I've seen.

Barry Bonds



Honus Wagner



Roberto Clemente



Willie Stargell