Thoughts on Diaz

general

Moderators: SammyKhalifa, Doc, Bobster

johnfluharty

Thoughts on Diaz

Post by johnfluharty »

2B20282421203B7E780F362E272020612C204F0 wrote: Cervelli is mad of glass.  It's an issue.  He's not a quality ML catcher because he's always hurt.   He will have two consecutive years with less than 400 plate appearances.   



1.6 WAR last year

0.9 War this year



Yeah baby.  "Quality"

So what now? 


Diaz is -0.2 in WAR.



Cervelli gets dinged up more than any catcher I have ever seen.  Not sure why he takes so many foul tips off his body compared to others.  He still should play over Diaz.




Diaz doesn't have enough time in for his WAR to have any significant meaning.
dogknot17@yahoo.co

Thoughts on Diaz

Post by dogknot17@yahoo.co »

424740464E445D40495A5C51280 wrote: Cervelli is mad of glass.  It's an issue.  He's not a quality ML catcher because he's always hurt.   He will have two consecutive years with less than 400 plate appearances.   



1.6 WAR last year

0.9 War this year



Yeah baby.  "Quality"

So what now? 


Diaz is -0.2 in WAR.



Cervelli gets dinged up more than any catcher I have ever seen.  Not sure why he takes so many foul tips off his body compared to others.  He still should play over Diaz.




Diaz doesn't have enough time in for his WAR to have any significant meaning.


Cervelli's WAR was 1.1 in 2014 when he had nine more at bats and 50 more innings caught than Diaz has now.



I don't like that stat, just pointing it out since it was used.
dmetz
Posts: 1687
Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2016 4:52 pm

Thoughts on Diaz

Post by dmetz »

4249414D4849521711665F474E4949084549260 wrote: Cervelli is mad of glass.  It's an issue.  He's not a quality ML catcher because he's always hurt.   He will have two consecutive years with less than 400 plate appearances.   



1.6 WAR last year

0.9 War this year



Yeah baby.  "Quality"

So what now? 


Diaz is -0.2 in WAR.



Cervelli gets dinged up more than any catcher I have ever seen.  Not sure why he takes so many foul tips off his body compared to others.  He still should play over Diaz.




So what are you saying? You're agreeing with me that we have a problem at catcher?



Cervelli hasn't been good and can't stay healthy and you're saying Diaz is clearly worse.



Didn't you say there wasn't a problem? Or is your goal just to defend Cervelli for some reason. I don't get it
dmetz
Posts: 1687
Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2016 4:52 pm

Thoughts on Diaz

Post by dmetz »

7A71797570716A2F295E677F767171307D711E0 wrote: Cervelli is mad of glass.  It's an issue.  He's not a quality ML catcher because he's always hurt.   He will have two consecutive years with less than 400 plate appearances.   



1.6 WAR last year

0.9 War this year



Yeah baby.  "Quality"

So what now? 


Diaz is -0.2 in WAR.



Cervelli gets dinged up more than any catcher I have ever seen.  Not sure why he takes so many foul tips off his body compared to others.  He still should play over Diaz.




Diaz doesn't have enough time in for his WAR to have any significant meaning.


Cervelli's WAR was 1.1 in 2014 when he had nine more at bats and 50 more innings caught than Diaz has now.



I don't like that stat, just pointing it out since it was used. 




So...3 years ago Cervelli was better than Diaz is now? Got it! So Diaz isn't looking very good, neither is Cervelli now. So we do or we don't have a problem at catcher?


SCBucco
Posts: 1791
Joined: Tue Sep 13, 2016 11:47 am

Thoughts on Diaz

Post by SCBucco »

66474F664D45220 wrote: He will be #2 next season cause he is cheaper than Stewart!   ::)


He is also better than Stewart.
dogknot17@yahoo.co

Thoughts on Diaz

Post by dogknot17@yahoo.co »

626B63727C060 wrote: Cervelli is mad of glass.  It's an issue.  He's not a quality ML catcher because he's always hurt.   He will have two consecutive years with less than 400 plate appearances.   



1.6 WAR last year

0.9 War this year



Yeah baby.  "Quality"

So what now? 


Diaz is -0.2 in WAR.



Cervelli gets dinged up more than any catcher I have ever seen.  Not sure why he takes so many foul tips off his body compared to others.  He still should play over Diaz.




Diaz doesn't have enough time in for his WAR to have any significant meaning.


Cervelli's WAR was 1.1 in 2014 when he had nine more at bats and 50 more innings caught than Diaz has now.



I don't like that stat, just pointing it out since it was used. 




So...3 years ago Cervelli was better than Diaz is now?  Got it!  So Diaz isn't looking very good, neither is Cervelli now.  So we do or we don't have a problem at catcher?






Pointing out that in a small sample size, Cervelli still had a better WAR than Diaz. It was brought up that there wasn't enough time for Diaz to have a significant WAR this year. When Cervelli didn't have enough time to have a significant WAR, it was still better than Diaz.



Cervelli is better than Diaz. I don't know if there is a problem at catcher. A healthy Cervelli is best for the team. Cervelli gets dinged more than any other catcher I have seen. I don't know why and I hope it is just a coincidence.
johnfluharty

Thoughts on Diaz

Post by johnfluharty »

Cervelli played less than half a year.
Post Reply