If a batter is hit by the pitch on a 3-ball count, it goes as a HBP instead of a walk, so it doesn't count against the pitcher's WHIP. But if the batter had managed to avoid the pitch, it would have been ball-4 and increased the pitcher's WHIP. So WHIP is intended to show the average number of base runners a pitcher allows per inning via hits and walks unless he hits a batter even on what would have otherwise been a walk. Maybe they shouldn't count infield hits against the WHIP either. It would make just as much sense.
Bobster wrote: ↑Fri Apr 18, 2025 12:19 pm
WHIP is a strange stat.
Hits + walks / innings pitched.
If a batter is hit by the pitch on a 3-ball count, it goes as a HBP instead of a walk, so it doesn't count against the pitcher's WHIP. But if the batter had managed to avoid the pitch, it would have been ball-4 and increased the pitcher's WHIP. So WHIP is intended to show the average number of base runners a pitcher allows per inning via hits and walks unless he hits a batter even on what would have otherwise been a walk. Maybe they shouldn't count infield hits against the WHIP either. It would make just as much sense.
I remember as a kid we had a strat-o-matic baseball league in the neighborhood. One person kept score by counting HBP as walks. There was a big discussion on this as everyone else had it as a separate category. Of course we didn't know about WHIP back then.