OnlyBucs

Wildwoodcoach wrote: ↑Mon Apr 01, 2024 12:03 am It is a great start. Really liked how the bucs fell behind a few times
in this series and came back to win. I don't think any of us felt that the bucs would sweep this four game series.
Have one question. Is it too early to pull the plug on Falter? I have no confidence in him

Surgnbuck wrote: ↑Mon Apr 01, 2024 12:41 am

Wildwoodcoach wrote: ↑Mon Apr 01, 2024 12:03 am It is a great start. Really liked how the bucs fell behind a few times
in this series and came back to win. I don't think any of us felt that the bucs would sweep this four game series.
Have one question. Is it too early to pull the plug on Falter? I have no confidence in him

I don't think it's too early, but from a replacement standpoint, he's probably going to have to make another 3-5 starts. Ortiz would have to get stretched back out, and maybe he's pitching so well because he's embraced the bullpen role. I don't have any more confidence in Contreras to replace Falter.

After his start against the Orioles, they could skip a start, and his next time up would be the last game against the Mets, and they could go bullpen game with the off day.

After that, they'd need him to make at least two more starts when the Pirates swing west. By the time the Pirates come home first week of May, Skenes and Priester will have made 4-5 starts, and we'll know where they're at by then. They could also try stretching Ortiz back out in those starts, and Falter could be used as an opener.

So yeah, it would be great to pull the plug on him, but we already know Skenes isn't coming up that soon, Ortiz isn't stretched out, Contreras is just a big a question mark.

Also, by that time they should have an idea where the newly acquired alky is at.

So I think we're stuck with Falter for at least 5 more weeks.

fjk090852-7 wrote: ↑Mon Apr 01, 2024 2:06 am

Surgnbuck wrote: ↑Mon Apr 01, 2024 12:41 am

Wildwoodcoach wrote: ↑Mon Apr 01, 2024 12:03 am It is a great start. Really liked how the bucs fell behind a few times
in this series and came back to win. I don't think any of us felt that the bucs would sweep this four game series.
Have one question. Is it too early to pull the plug on Falter? I have no confidence in him

I don't think it's too early, but from a replacement standpoint, he's probably going to have to make another 3-5 starts. Ortiz would have to get stretched back out, and maybe he's pitching so well because he's embraced the bullpen role. I don't have any more confidence in Contreras to replace Falter.

After his start against the Orioles, they could skip a start, and his next time up would be the last game against the Mets, and they could go bullpen game with the off day.

After that, they'd need him to make at least two more starts when the Pirates swing west. By the time the Pirates come home first week of May, Skenes and Priester will have made 4-5 starts, and we'll know where they're at by then. They could also try stretching Ortiz back out in those starts, and Falter could be used as an opener.

So yeah, it would be great to pull the plug on him, but we already know Skenes isn't coming up that soon, Ortiz isn't stretched out, Contreras is just a big a question mark.

Also, by that time they should have an idea where the newly acquired alky is at.

So I think we're stuck with Falter for at least 5 more weeks.

If he pitches like today I cannot believe they would keep him in the rotation, or even on the roster for 5 weeks. He pitched poorly in ST, so at the minimum I would give him one additional start which will probably be Saturday.