7B6B6A5D4B4B47280 wrote: Well, we could ask for Lux and one of the LA catchers and throw in Vazquez as a sweetener...
This sadly made me laugh. That still p*sses me off. NH was looking for Lux in that LAD deal for Vasquez, when May and a catching prospect would have helped us more.
Do we know that for sure?
What could we get for Marte
Moderators: SammyKhalifa, Doc, Bobster
-
JollyRoger
- Posts: 1469
- Joined: Sat Jul 16, 2016 8:31 pm
What could we get for Marte
I don’t blame NH for the high asking price for Vazquez. Vazquez like Chapman before him was the most dominating reliever in baseball. Plus he had 4 years on control at team friendly cost. Look at what the Yankees got from the Cubs for Chapman.
Unfortunately the Dodgers value their prospects too high and are tough to get a deal done with.
I agree that we did not need Lux given our depth at 2B and SS.
However if we only received May and Ruiz I think a lot of Pirate fans would have been upset. I think Vazquez was worth more.
Who could have predicted that he would be out of baseball and a disgrace a month later
Unfortunately the Dodgers value their prospects too high and are tough to get a deal done with.
I agree that we did not need Lux given our depth at 2B and SS.
However if we only received May and Ruiz I think a lot of Pirate fans would have been upset. I think Vazquez was worth more.
Who could have predicted that he would be out of baseball and a disgrace a month later
-
SammyKhalifa
- Posts: 3642
- Joined: Fri Jul 01, 2016 4:19 am
What could we get for Marte
0D282B2B3E1528202235470 wrote: I don’t blame NH for the high asking price for Vazquez. Vazquez like Chapman before him was the most dominating reliever in baseball. Plus he had 4 years on control at team friendly cost. Look at what the Yankees got from the Cubs for Chapman.
Unfortunately the Dodgers value their prospects too high and are tough to get a deal done with.
I agree that we did not need Lux given our depth at 2B and SS.
However if we only received May and Ruiz I think a lot of Pirate fans would have been upset. I think Vazquez was worth more.
Who could have predicted that he would be out of baseball and a disgrace a month later
See, I remember hearing that May and Ruiz (maybe +1) was actually NH's offer and LA turned him down. I'm pretty sure the Lux thing came about on speculation too.
Unfortunately the Dodgers value their prospects too high and are tough to get a deal done with.
I agree that we did not need Lux given our depth at 2B and SS.
However if we only received May and Ruiz I think a lot of Pirate fans would have been upset. I think Vazquez was worth more.
Who could have predicted that he would be out of baseball and a disgrace a month later
See, I remember hearing that May and Ruiz (maybe +1) was actually NH's offer and LA turned him down. I'm pretty sure the Lux thing came about on speculation too.
What could we get for Marte
I saw this on ESPN listing a blockbuster move for all 30 teams:
Pittsburgh Pirates trade OF Starling Marte, RHP Chris Archer and RHP Keone Kela to the New York Mets for 1B/LF Dominic Smith, LHP David Peterson and RHP Stephen Nogosek. I honestly don't know enough about the Mets to know if that is a fair trade. The write up for what the pirates are getting didn't woo me.
Pittsburgh Pirates trade OF Starling Marte, RHP Chris Archer and RHP Keone Kela to the New York Mets for 1B/LF Dominic Smith, LHP David Peterson and RHP Stephen Nogosek. I honestly don't know enough about the Mets to know if that is a fair trade. The write up for what the pirates are getting didn't woo me.
What could we get for Marte
As noted earlier in this thread by P Mike - the identified return from the Mets is a bit underwhelming.
About the only advantage to the Pirates in making a trade like this is that it would clear out nearly all of the team's salary obligations (cue in Nutting smiles). That said, if the Bucs are making trades, they need to obtain as much talent as possible in return.
Hoping that BC can obtain a good (make that a great) return for Marte at the winter meetings. Although there is not a lot of CF talent on the free agent market, the premium free agents appear to be finding new landing spots earlier this off-season. Don't want to see the Bucs hang on to Marte for too long where his potential suitors start to dry up.
About the only advantage to the Pirates in making a trade like this is that it would clear out nearly all of the team's salary obligations (cue in Nutting smiles). That said, if the Bucs are making trades, they need to obtain as much talent as possible in return.
Hoping that BC can obtain a good (make that a great) return for Marte at the winter meetings. Although there is not a lot of CF talent on the free agent market, the premium free agents appear to be finding new landing spots earlier this off-season. Don't want to see the Bucs hang on to Marte for too long where his potential suitors start to dry up.
What could we get for Marte
4F474453454549260 wrote: I saw this on ESPN listing a blockbuster move for all 30 teams:
Pittsburgh Pirates trade OF Starling Marte, RHP Chris Archer and RHP Keone Kela to the New York Mets for 1B/LF Dominic Smith, LHP David Peterson and RHP Stephen Nogosek. I honestly don't know enough about the Mets to know if that is a fair trade. The write up for what the pirates are getting didn't woo me.
I think this trade makes including Archer a salary dump. Dominic Smith can't play left in PNC. So the Bucs would need to trade Bell too (or try and flip Smith to someone). To me, Marte is worth at least 2 of these 3 Mets prospects.
Pittsburgh Pirates trade OF Starling Marte, RHP Chris Archer and RHP Keone Kela to the New York Mets for 1B/LF Dominic Smith, LHP David Peterson and RHP Stephen Nogosek. I honestly don't know enough about the Mets to know if that is a fair trade. The write up for what the pirates are getting didn't woo me.
I think this trade makes including Archer a salary dump. Dominic Smith can't play left in PNC. So the Bucs would need to trade Bell too (or try and flip Smith to someone). To me, Marte is worth at least 2 of these 3 Mets prospects.
-
DemDog
What could we get for Marte
676F6C7B6D6D610E0 wrote: I saw this on ESPN listing a blockbuster move for all 30 teams:
Pittsburgh Pirates trade OF Starling Marte, RHP Chris Archer and RHP Keone Kela to the New York Mets for 1B/LF Dominic Smith, LHP David Peterson and RHP Stephen Nogosek. I honestly don't know enough about the Mets to know if that is a fair trade. The write up for what the pirates are getting didn't woo me.
Here is where BC and his guy Sanders need to look at the 2 pitchers. Peterson is the #2 pitching prospect and #7 overall. The other 2 are not rated among the top 30 with Smith no longer a prospect. But from BBR he looks like less than adequate LF especially in PNC and he does not seem to have the big time pop in his bat. But at 24 maybe the new regime in the Burgh can help him out.
Pittsburgh Pirates trade OF Starling Marte, RHP Chris Archer and RHP Keone Kela to the New York Mets for 1B/LF Dominic Smith, LHP David Peterson and RHP Stephen Nogosek. I honestly don't know enough about the Mets to know if that is a fair trade. The write up for what the pirates are getting didn't woo me.
Here is where BC and his guy Sanders need to look at the 2 pitchers. Peterson is the #2 pitching prospect and #7 overall. The other 2 are not rated among the top 30 with Smith no longer a prospect. But from BBR he looks like less than adequate LF especially in PNC and he does not seem to have the big time pop in his bat. But at 24 maybe the new regime in the Burgh can help him out.
What could we get for Marte
Looks like the Mets are out.
Mets acquire OF Jake Marisnick in trade with Astros
Mets acquire OF Jake Marisnick in trade with Astros
What could we get for Marte
10373C1F520 wrote: Looks like the Mets are out.
Mets acquire OF Jake Marisnick in trade with Astros
SD might have the most intriguing possibilities here for Marte.
Mets acquire OF Jake Marisnick in trade with Astros
SD might have the most intriguing possibilities here for Marte.
What could we get for Marte
So, I just read on the Atlantic a piece by Jim Bowden saying a move or two each team should make. He posed on for everyone, but two for the Bucs. I love one idea, but hate the other.
Marte to the Reds for Mahle, Winker and India
Bell to the Yanks for Andujar, Voit and Contreras
The problem if we do both of these, we won't, there isn't a catcher or a catching prospect among either deal. And we don't get a good pitcher for the rotation.
Marte to the Reds for Mahle, Winker and India
Bell to the Yanks for Andujar, Voit and Contreras
The problem if we do both of these, we won't, there isn't a catcher or a catching prospect among either deal. And we don't get a good pitcher for the rotation.